The Historian as Detective: Essays on Evidence

His sympathetic account of the special challenges faced by Canadian literatureis clear, accurate, and well worth reading: "To one who takes careful accountof the difficulties which have steadily beset its growth its survival assomething interesting and important seems a miracle."]




(1837)[Play]




(1872) [Historical essays]




The Historian as Detective: Essays on Evidence.

Robin W. Winks, author of The Historian As Detective: Essays on Evidence, on LibraryThing

The Historian as Detective: Essays on Evidence ..

Raverat was a granddaughter of Charles Darwin]




(1913)[Historical biographies: with many portraits of the viceregal luminariesby Ontario illustrator James Everett Laughlin (1870-1944)]




(1914; initial essay first published in 1909)[Essays on the history of the Hudson's Bay Company, on the fur trade, and on Louisiana]




Learn Something Old! | Plimoth Plantation

Murray explains his strong belief that the German government was responsible fortriggering the First World War, a belief unlikely to have encountered much disagreement amongthe members of the Fight for Right League, to whom this address was originally delivered.]
(1948)[The 1947 Andrew Lang Lectureon the poetry of Andrew Lang (1844-1912),better known in 1947 and today as a folklorist and historian than as a poet.]

The panel heard new evidence that the testimony of a key witness was tainted by a hypnosis session utilizing outdated science.
As students of history, they should realize that the textbook is a collection of evidence waiting for interpretation.

Free Peter The Great Essays and Papers - 123HelpMe

[The historian] finds furthermore that there are varioussorts of obligations laid upon him to refrain from truth-telling under diversepenalties. He is a member of a state, a church, a party, a class, a clique, afamily, and in all these relations he is virtually obliged to see things asthey are not, and to speak that which is false, under penalties varying fromexecution down to mere inarticulate unpopularity, most difficult to be borne.(“The Case of the Eyewitnesses,” in Robin Winks, editor, , 1968, p. 190)

Critical insight into the  of detective fiction: “In the end, like history, such fiction appears to and occasionally does, decode the environment .

The Classical Hollywood Cinema Twenty-Five Years Along

History has generously provided analogous cases in which new evidencehas dramatically reversed the earlier verdict of history. Previous authors have citedthe French character assassination of Alfred Dreyfus (between 1894 and 1906)for its similarity to the JFK assassination. Indeed, because of its manylessons, I have summarized this case in Addendum 3. Based on forged documents,Dreyfus was convicted of passing French military secrets to the Germans. Themost obvious feature of both controversies was their stubborn unwillingness todie. Each was a chronic, festering wound in the body politic, though theDreyfus affair was settled much more quickly.

The detective or historian, with question four, seeks to establish the reliability of the evidence at hand, ..

Writer of essays, sayer of things and ever sticking out

The JFK assassination may also be the best historical exampleof disparate facts that make no sense at all within a particular logicalstructure (the one erected by the Warren Commission), but which suddenly becomeluminous when seen through the lens of an alternate hypothesis. Examples arethe bullets that several witnesses either saw or heard strike Elm Street. Theirreports are included in the Warren Commission’s 26 volumes of supportingevidence, but are totally ignored and never explained in the 888-page reportitself. Other examples are the 6.5 mm “bullet” cross section at the back of thehead on the JFK skull X-rays, an object that no one reported until 1968, or thevery long list of apparently disparate facts that suddenly fell into place whenDouglas P. Horne proposed two separate examinations of two different brains ontwo different dates.The explanatory power of the new paradigm is striking, embarrassingly so whencompared to the old one (). The number of old, previously ignored, facts that suddenly comealive, like Pinocchio, is astonishing. The examples cited in this paragraph aremerely a small cross section of the entire case.